News

Surprising No One, GTA 6's Comedy Is All Over the Place

0
Please log in or register to do it.
Surprising No One, GTA 6's Comedy Is All Over the Place

From the moment Grand Theft Auto 6 was first announced, I had little doubt that developer Rockstar Games would be able to deliver a high-quality game. Any minor worries I had that the studio’s approach to open-world design might have become dated in the eight years since Red Dead Redemption 2 went away as soon as I started exploring the impressively constructed world of Leonida. But there’s one thing I was far less certain of: the satire of it all.

More than being deviously fun crime sandboxes, every Grand Theft Auto game also acts as a snapshot of American culture at the time of its release. These games have never pulled any punches, taking swings at everything from the paparazzi to politics to the most innocuous corners of pop culture. GTA 6 was sure to take the same shots, but at a time when the targets are moving faster than ever. Could a game that has been in the works for more than a decade possibly have humor that felt up to date? Would it be careful to punch up rather than turn the country’s most vulnerable people into punchlines? And would it have the stones to take on President Donald Trump, a man who has dominated America’s political culture throughout the game’s entire development cycle?

PolygonInteractive

Stats Screen

Gaming•Quizzes•Grand Theft Auto

Save FileFive Ways To Spend It
100% completeCompletionist
0 missionsCruiser
0 ticketsRoleplayer
Credits reachedStory
412 hoursCrew

Polygon QuizWhat Kind of GTA
Player Are You?
8 Questions • 5 TypesTwo people can put two hundred hours into the same game and have played completely different things. One of them finished the story in a weekend. One of them has never started a mission and could not be happier. Eight questions about your habits will say which of the five you are.The Five Types

The Completionist
The Cruiser
The Roleplayer
The Story Player
The Crew Player

Checkpoint 01 of 080% Logged

Question 01HOUR ONE
01Fresh save, first hour. What are you doing with it?Everybody’s first hour looks completely different.
Pick one, then Next

Checkpoint 02 of 0812% Logged

Question 02THE WAYPOINT
02There is a waypoint on your map. How long until you reach it?The honest answer, not the one on the screen.
Pick one, then Next

Checkpoint 03 of 0825% Logged

Question 03RED LIGHT
03Red light, empty junction, nobody around.This question has never once failed to separate people.
Pick one, then Next

Checkpoint 04 of 0838% Logged

Question 04A CAR YOU LIKE
04You find a car you like. What happens to it?There is a correct answer and nobody agrees what it is.
Pick one, then Next

Checkpoint 05 of 0850% Logged

Question 05A ROUND OF GOLF
05The game offers you a full round of golf. Yes or no?Nine holes. Real time. Your call.
Pick one, then Next

Checkpoint 06 of 0862% Logged

Question 06IT GOES WRONG
06A mission goes wrong right at the end.Two seconds to decide what kind of player you are.
Pick one, then Next

Checkpoint 07 of 0875% Logged

Question 07THE CREDITS
07The credits roll. What happens after that?For some people this is the end and for some people it is nothing.
Pick one, then Next

Checkpoint 08 of 0888% Logged

Question 08THE HOURS
08Where did your hours really go?This is the one that decides it.
Pick one, then Next

Save LoadedYou Are
Nobody is playing it wrong. These are five honest ways to spend the hours, and your
answers keep landing on one of them.

100% completeThe CompletionistCollectibles / Side activities / A numberThere is a number, and it is not at 100 yet.

You cannot leave a map with things still on it. The percentage is the real game, the story is one more item on the list, and you will clear everything between here and the waypoint first.Why That Is You

  • The completion percentage is the only tally GTA keeps, and for you it is the whole reason
    the hours are worth counting.
  • Your first hour goes on the collectibles menu, working out the size of the job before you
    start it.
  • A mission that goes wrong gets replayed until it is clean, because there is a rating
    attached and you are going for it.
  • You were still at 68 percent when the credits rolled, and the credits did not feel like an
    ending.
100%Clears The MapWants The Rating

0 missions, 8,431 milesThe CruiserRadio on / No waypoint / Just drivingYou never started the mission, and that was the point.

Radio on, no waypoint, nowhere to be. The city is the game for you, and the story is an interruption you have been politely declining for about forty hours.Why That Is You

  • GTA spends more effort on the feel of a car at night than on almost anything else, and you
    are the player that work was for.
  • There is a waypoint on your map and you may never reach it, because the drive is better than
    the arrival.
  • You have one car, you drive it everywhere, and you know exactly where you parked it.
  • The credits rolled and nothing changed. You are still out there with the radio on.
Radio OnNo WaypointJust Driving

0 tickets, parked neatlyThe RoleplayerIn character / Indicates / ReloadsYou indicate at junctions and you mean it.

You are not playing a game, you are living somewhere. You stop at lights, you park between the lines, and when something happens that would not have happened, you reload.Why That Is You

  • Stopping at a red light in an empty city is a choice nobody asks you to make, which is
    exactly why you make it.
  • Your first hour goes on the camera, the controls and the radio, set precisely how you want
    them before anything begins.
  • You reload after a mission goes wrong, not for the rating, but because that is not how it
    would have gone.
  • After the credits you keep playing him, because as far as you are concerned he lives there
    now.
In CharacterParks NeatlyReloads

Credits reached, 34 hoursThe Story PlayerStraight through / Credits / Next gameYou came for the story and left when it ended.

Straight down the line, no detours, finished in a handful of long sittings. You are not missing anything. You came for the thing the game was built to tell you, and you got it.Why That Is You

  • You start the story in hour one and you do not stop until something outside the game makes
    you, which is how these games are written to be played.
  • Offered a full round of golf, you say no, because you are in the middle of something.
  • A car you like gets left wherever the next mission starts. It was transport, not a
    relationship.
  • Credits roll, that is it, done, on to the next game, and you have no regrets about any of
    it.
Straight ThroughNo DetoursNext Game

412 hours, four of youThe Crew PlayerFriends / No plan / Two years inNone of it counts unless the others are on.

You are not really playing a game, you are hanging out, and the game is where it happens. You could not tell anybody what you did for the last four hundred hours and you had a great time.Why That Is You

  • This is the player the series quietly became about, and it is the reason people are still in
    these cities a decade later.
  • Your first hour is spent waiting for everyone to get on, because alone it is a different
    game entirely.
  • You found a car you liked and somebody else drove it into the sea, and that was the best
    thing that happened all evening.
  • You could not tell anyone where the hours went, and that is not a complaint.
Four Of YouNo PlanStill Online

Closest Matches
1• • •0%
2• • •0%
3• • •0%

Copied
A Polygon InteractivePolygonMore quizzes at polygon.com

GTA 6 - couple in car
Image: Rockstar Games

If you’re going into GTA 6 looking for a specific satirical worldview, you’re bound to be disappointed. Rockstar’s continued commitment to making fun of literally everyone ensures that it will throw our current culture war for a loop. Everyone will have a reason to be mad about it — and everyone will have a reason to claim it as a victory, too.

Historically, GTA’s humor can be described as “South Park-core.” The series found its voice in an early 2000s era where the dominant philosophy of comedy was that it was okay to make fun of everything, so long as the ridicule was handed out in equal measure. There was little difference between going after George W. Bush or Terri Schiavo; both were treated as current events to be riffed on despite the gulf of difference between them. GTA was built on this kind of edgy topical humor, for better and certainly worse at times.

Comedy has evolved since then, and GTA 6 does reflect that change… up to a point. It’s a little more careful in its choice of targets, largely keeping its focus on rich weirdos, crypto scammers, conservative conspiracy theorists, and more of modern culture’s biggest weirdos. For instance, turn on the radio and you might catch a right-wing sportscaster ranting about trans athletes in sports. The punchline comes when the host starts talking about how much he cares about girls’ sports, creepily making a point to note how “beautiful” all those young ladies are. The intended target of that bit is transphobes, as GTA 6 paints men who care too much about youth sports as pedophiles using hate as a cover.

Jason holds up a phone while driving in GTA 6
Image: Rockstar Games via Polygon

That brand of humor already seems to be striking a nerve with the right people. Search “GTA 6 woke” on X, if you dare, and you’ll find plenty of engagement-baiting comments from the usual suspects whining about it. It will be tempting to pull out some isolated moments, or reactions to them, and declare that GTA has undergone a full change in consciousness that sticks it to the bigots rather than punching down on the people they target.

That sunny read will only get you so far, though. GTA 6 still does have the same approach to satire that the series has always taken, and some weird targets wind up in its crosshairs. Gags about hippie animal rights activists who want to free chimpanzees from an animal sanctuary, for instance, feel oddly dated, a vestige of 2000s cultural satire — not offensive, just ancient. GTA 6 also doesn’t spare a lot of sympathy for those battling substance abuse, giving Jason and Lucia stereotypical “addicts” to rough up. Caricatures are still doled out in abundance in a game that goes out of its way to include a loaded scene where Lucia strikes back against a bigot who launches a racist tirade against her. Anyone who wants to celebrate that GTA hasn’t lost its edgy tone will have plenty of data on the other side of the political spectrum for confirmation.

Then there’s the gray area between those two extremes. There are moments where GTA 6’s satire will draw fire from all sides. At one point while chilling in Jason and Lucia’s apartment, I flipped on the TV to catch a cartoon. It starred Right-Wing, a superhero who serves the president. The episode revolved around the president tasking Right-Wing with rounding up gay people using a “gaydar.” It’s not clever comedy, but its intent is to lampoon homophobic conservatives. The episode hurtles towards a low-hanging punchline, though, where it implies that Right-Wing is a closeted gay man himself. It’s the kind of backwards humor built to pop a certain kind of neoliberal who thinks that the best way to stick it to Donald Trump is to imply that he’s secretly having sex with Vladimir Putin.

Lucia stands in front of a whiskey billboard in GTA 6
Image: Rockstar Games via Polygon

The scattershot collection of jokes shows why social satire can be such a delicate operation. There’s a fine line between making a point through heightened comedy, and just repeating the thing you’re making fun of, but with a knowing wink. There’s not always a punchline when shock jocks are on air ranting about immigrants; sometimes the joke is just that guys like that exist. Yes, and? Like previous games in the series, GTA 6 can feel more invested in farce than satire, and that’s the point where players would be right to ask who’s really getting the last laugh.

Even if the punchlines aren’t always clean, there’s undeniably a function to all of GTA 6’s political gags on a broader level. In a series of developer quotes sent out to reviewers, senior vice president of narrative Rupert Humphries explained how every bit of satire is working in service of a powder-keg atmosphere that’s crucial to understanding Jason and Lucia’s journey.

Surprising No One, GTA 6's Comedy Is All Over the Place
Free sign-up

Get Polygon’s Wishlister newsletter

A weekly cheat sheet to what you’ll eventually love to play. No buying, no
commitment — just saving for later.


Sign up free

Free. Unsubscribe anytime.

“Living in the actual world in this present moment, it feels like there is so much noise and so much pressure on everyone — politics, the environment, media, social media. It’s coming at you from everywhere,” Humphries wrote. “It seems like we are all about two bits of bad luck away from completely losing it. That is the world we are showing you on the streets of Vice City and in the rest of Leonida — everyone’s been driven to a kind of madness that comes out in lots of different ways, from conspiracy theories to self-help cults to get-rich-quick schemes and drug habits.”

That approach may work for players long-term in context of GTA 6’s big picture, but the reactions to its moment-to-moment gags are bound to stir up some heated debates — as they should. Satire is meant to provoke and push us to ask questions about the world that is being lampooned. We stand to learn more about our cultural climate from how GTA 6 is dissected and remembered 13 years from now. If it doesn’t feel dated by the time GTA 7 comes out, it will be a bad sign for modern society. But in the meantime, everyone is going to find something to get mad about in GTA 6.

Source: www.polygon.com — Read the original article

New Fallout Game Leaks and Is Puzzling Players
The Game Awards’ Biggest GOTY Snub Has Been Officially Redeemed

Reactions

0
0
0
0
0
0
Already reacted for this post.

Reactions

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

GIF